Saturday, June 7, 2014

USS Liberty: 47 Years of Lies

USS Liberty: 47 Years of Lies

By James Ennes

Damaged USS Liberty / US Navy photo Caption ba...
Damaged USS Liberty / US Navy photo Caption bar formerly at top read: :Photo # NH 97478 Damage to USS Liberty, June 1967 (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
SINCE JUNE 8, 1967, when Israeli air and naval forces deliberately attacked the American intelligence ship USS Liberty,Israel and its American supporters have lied about what happened.
The facts are simple and straightforward. Israeli forces reconnoitered the ship for hours in daylight with unlimited visibility, correctly reported the ship’s identity to their headquarters, then attacked the clearly marked and defenseless American ship by air and sea for more than 75 minutes, killing 34 men and wounding more than two-thirds of the 297-man crew.
After disabling the ship with a 40-foot torpedo hole and hundreds of canon and missile hits, Israeli torpedomen continued to fire from as little as 50 feet away. They ignored the oversize American flag that flew in plain sight from the mast while firing on medical personnel and firefighters nearby. Finally, as preparations were being made to abandon ship, they machine-gunned the ship’s empty life rafts which had been lowered into the water awaiting survivors—a clear violation of Geneva conventions.
The lies started almost immediately. Even before crewmen could give their eyewitness accounts, the Israeli government concocted a preposterous “tragic accident” story, claiming that the Liberty had been mistaken for an out-of-service Egyptian horse carrier designed to carry 40 horses and their riders for the Egyptian cavalry of the 1920s. According to this story, the Liberty was recognized as American only after torpedoes were launched. Since torpedoes can’t be recalled or redirected, however, Americans died. According to the Israeli story, the attackers immediately ceased fire and apologized for their “mistake.”
But this was not true. The torpedomen continued to fire long after they claim the last shot was fired. In fact, they continued to fire until they heard that air support from the Sixth Fleet was on the way.
Survivors of the attack fully expected to refute the Israeli lie during one of the investigations that would be sure to follow, and show that the attack was no accident. That, however, was not to be.
Despite the presence of more than 200 men eager to testify, the Navy Court of Inquiry inexplicably did not ask about deliberateness, and did not allow survivors to testify freely—nor did Congress or anyone else. Israel’s “Big Lie” was accepted at face value, and no questions were ever asked about whether the attack was deliberate or whether the Israeli story was true.
Ward Boston
Ward Boston was the Legal Advisor to the US Navy Court that was convened in the wake of the attack on the USS Liberty.
According to a sworn affidavit by the Court’s own legal officer, the official Navy transcript was fraudulently changed and rewritten in Washington after it was signed by members of the Court. The official record, therefore, is a forgery. Yet despite several appeals to the secretary of the Navy and others, the Navy refuses to investigate or even to contact the senior legal officer making these very serious charges (
Survivors of the Israeli attack have spent most of the ensuing 40 years trying in vain to right these wrongs, but have been frustrated at every turn. Israel’s attack on the USS Liberty remains the only major maritime incident in American history not investigated by Congress. Queries to Congress bring boilerplate replies and no serious attention. Why? Because the attack by Israel on the USSLiberty is simply too politically sensitive.
Individually, nearly everyone in government with knowledge of the attack agrees that it was deliberate. Dozens of senior officials, including White House advisers and most senior intelligence agency leaders, agree that Israel deliberately attacked a ship it knew to be American (see A diplomatic note sent by Secretary of State Dean Rusk to Israel asserted our government’s disbelief in the Israeli story. Yet such notes were withheld from the public until years later, and the private views remained mostly private. Even today, over 40 years later, former Sen. Adlai Stevenson III (D-IL) is one of the few elected officials who had the courage to tell the truth about this attack while still in office.
Survivors’ frustration is made worse by various spokesmen for the attackers such as Florida Bankruptcy Magistrate Ahron Jay Cristol and FLAME president Gerardo Joffe.
Cristol first gave serious currency to “The Big Lie” when his book, The Liberty Incident, falsely claimed that up to 15 investigations “including five congressional investigations” had all inquired into the attack and exonerated Israel of any wrongdoing.
As we have demonstrated previously that is totally untrue. No American investigation has ever inquired as to whether the attack was deliberate. Certainly no congressional inquiry has done so. Cristol’s dishonest tactic is to find a mention of the attack in some official record and call this an “investigation that exonerated Israel.”
For instance, Cristol cites a 1968 remark by then-Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara in an unrelated hearing asserting that the attack was not deliberate, while ignoring the conclusion of the hearing chairman Bourke Hickenlooper that “I have read [the reports] and I cannot agree that it was accidental.” Yet Cristol ignores Hickenlooper’s opinion and reports the hearing as supporting the “tragic accident” position.
Similarly, none of the “five congressional investigations” so often cited by Cristol were in fact investigations at all. None established or asserted Israeli innocence. But that does not stop Cristol from endlessly claiming that it does, and citing these and other fictitious sources as proof of Israeli innocence.
Sadly, other sycophants pick up Cristol’s ball and run with it. Perhaps most persistent is one Gerardo Joffe, president and chief cheerleader for the pro-Israel propaganda group FLAME—an acronym its critics maintain stands for “Fallacies and Lies About the Middle East.” In kneejerk letters to the Washington Report and in his FLAME Web site Joffe consistently parrots Cristol’s line that the Liberty attack has long been proven accidental and that it has been given too much attention, while other incidents are given too little.
Similarly, the Anti-Defamation League, whose stated mission is to stop defamation of the Jewish people and “to secure justice and fair treatment to all,” has no problem supporting the Cristol/FLAME fiction by pretending, according to its Web site, that “Several government investigations have concluded that the attack…was carried out in error” and that “every piece of information declassified to date…has supported this conclusion.”
Survivors repeatedly have asked Cristol and others to provide copies or other evidence of these so-called “investigations.” None has done so. They cannot. There are no such investigations. Similarly, we have asked them to remove their false statements. They refuse. These lies serve their purpose.
In fact, when survivors have sought details of such investigations from their congressmen, from the Navy Judge Advocate General, from the Library of Congress, from the Congressional Research Service, or from any other government agency, we have repeatedly been advised that there has never been any congressional investigation of Israel’s attack on the USS Liberty.
Most recently, on July 25, 2006, in response to a query from Liberty survivors, the Librarian of Congress wrote:
“After checking numerous resources, including the CIS (Congressional Information Service) Indexes to Congressional Hearings (both published and unpublished), and the Public Documents Masterfile, I could find no evidence that the Congress ever held hearings or launched an investigation into the June 8, 1967 incident with the USS Liberty. LC Control Number: 98135843.”
That should settle the issue for all time and bring Cristol, Joffe, ADL and other myopic Israel-can-do-no-wrongers to cease their never-ending claim that Israel has been exonerated by numerous investigations. That simply is not true, never has been true and never will be true, despite their blind determination to deny reality.
(Jim Ennes is a USS Liberty survivor and author of “Assault on the Liberty” the definitive account of the June 8, 1967 Israeli attack on the USS Liberty and can be reached through his website at


  1. The June 8, 1967 attack on the U.S.S. ( United States Ship ) Liberty is a day that will forever live in infamy in the minds of the now few survivors of the craven sneak attack that occurred on that quiet and clear day. On that quiet and clear day, the intelligence-gathering American ship, while embarked on its lawful business in international waters and flying a standard ship-sized American flag...was suddenly attacked by forces of the Israeli air-force and navy. In the wake of the unprovoked attack, 34 American sailors lay dead and almost 200 were grievously wounded. The sailors who were not murdered in the initial attack that consisted of Israeli fighter/bomber aircraft sorties...bombs and murderous machine gun fire...were straffed by machinegun fire by Israeli gunships as the sailors sought to abandon the doomed ship by lifeboat. The Articles of the Geneva Convention, enacted in the wake of the carnage of WWII, prohibit the murder of non-combatants by military forces, whether during time of war or not. According to International Law, civilians ( non-combatants ) are, even during times of war, exempt from attack by the military of a hostile force. The sailors aboard the Liberty were a military force, to be sure, but they were not engaged in military action. They were thus murdered. It is a foul testimony via the Laws of War that these unfortunate men met their untimely deaths via illegal action. The bastard "State" that is Israel, though, sets its own rules of war, rules of war that are in violation of every internationally accepted rules of conflict...war. The foul and historically murderous "state" of Israel consistently and with impunity violates the rules of war as set forth by the Community of Nations, i.e., the United Nations ( UN ). The cur dog that is the nation of Israel, though, considers itself to be immune from...exempt from...the rules of conduct that govern every other "advanced" nation on earth. But informed people of every advanced...i.e., intelligent...nation on this sad planet know when right is right and wrong is wrong. The Israeli government knows, of course, that it is an illegitimate government, to say the least. The "state" of Israel is, at best, an artificially contrived so-called state that was contrived by the debased, dissolute, now degenerate nation of "Great" Britain via the Lord Arthur Balfour Declaration of 1947. Evidence now exists to support the thesis that the denizens of the murderous "state" of Israel are NOT really the descendants of the ancient biblical Hebrews, i.e., Israelites, at all but, rather, an inbred peoples from southern Turkey, i.e., the Khazars, a vintage of people who have no blood or historical connection to the ancient Hebrews, subsequently called the Israelites, then, in time, Jews. The true origin...lineage...of the Tribe of people the world knows as the Jews is even now not fully known, and perhaps never will be. Human life is abundantly replete with as yet unsolved mysteries, and the ultimate origin of the so-called Jewish race is but one of them. The Jews, the Jews...the Chosen People of God Almighty Himself? Or the wicked, evil...spawn of the ultimate Anti-Christ...Satan himself? To return to the "first page," "square one": The unprovoked attack by the Israelis on the U.S. ship, Liberty, on June 8, 1967, was a most cowardly, dastardly attack by a so-called ally almost unparalleled in the history of the American Republic. The Jews...friend? Or foe?

  2. Today's "judeo-Christian" preachers will burn in the eternal fires of Hell for teaching the lie, devised by the Jews themselves, that this evil race is the Chosen People of God. Their actions alone, such as the attack on the U.S.S. Liberty, are straight from their father the devil. Oh, to have leaders that have eyes to see and ears to hear the Truth.